On a late April 1985 Saturday night near the end of my last law school semester, the professor who moderated our Law and Humanities course hosted us ten students at his spacious, high-ceilinged, white-walled, crown-molded, pre-War, Central Park West apartment, which is somewhere in the lower right of the photo above.
We shared dinner and discussed, with a guest of honor, a book he authored that provided the unifying thread for that course. In addition to that book, each week we read and discussed justice-related literature, including The Trial, Crime and Punishment, The Brothers Karamazov, Native Son, The Merchant of Venice and the Old Testament’s Book of Job. In preparation for that salon, we each submitted to the guest an essay about an unassigned book of our choosing that bore in some way on his book’s theme.
I enjoyed the soiree. As a son of parents who didn’t attend college, that evening was a cultural departure for me. Inter alia, I learned what crudites, merlot and brie were.
When we scattered around 11 PM, I headed back to New Jersey alone. The first leg of this trip was a twenty-minute downtown subway ride. From there, I walked further south through a narrow, barren, several-hundred-yards-long, low-ceilinged, underground tunnel toward the PATH station under the World Trade Center, from which the Jersey-bound trains departed.
The city had much more violent crime then than it’s had in subsequent decades. Given the time of night and the absence of nightlife in that part of town, for the first couple of minutes I was the only human in that tunnel. If I hadn’t been wearing sneakers, my footsteps would have echoed.
Then I saw in the distance two tall, young black males walking north toward me. As they got within thirty yards, the one on the right leaned toward his homeboy and whispered in his ear. The listener nodded assent and the pair continued in my direction.
Their conference raised apprehension. If they tried to mug me, I prepared to throw a punch or two, run and hope they didn’t pull out a weapon. I had no choice but to proceed south, toward them.
When they got five yards away, the one nearest me abruptly veered in my direction, made a hostile face and raised his left hand, as if he was going to smack me. I cocked my fist. Here we go.
Without breaking stride, he suddenly fake-smiled, exclaimed, “Heyyy, mannn!” and lifted his hand above his head to high-five me and continued walking.
As the city kids I worked with used to say, “Psych!”
As they passed and laughed, I frowned and grumbled, “You idiot.”
To them, the encounter was funny. To me, it was ten seconds of unappreciated drama. And kind of disrespectful.
—
For most of my life, I’ve lived a 30 to 45-minute bus or train ride from New York City. Over the years, I’ve spent many days and nights in many parts of that eight-plus-million-resident, 306 square miles of land or alongside or atop its 166 additional square miles of water. I like me some open-air Staten Island Ferry on a summer afternoon, or crossing the water at night while looking back toward a skyline of city lights twinkling in Jersey City, Manhattan and Brooklyn, separated by the black expanse of the harbor and the Hudson and East Rivers.
On a few of those trips, as above, untoward stuff happened. But I’ve enjoyed most of the time I’ve spent in NYC. The thousands of stylish buildings erected between 1880-1930 always please my eyes. I’ve very much liked playing outdoor ice hockey in the north end of Central Park and basketball in the West 4th St. cage (with black guys who treated me well), hearing semi-famous bands in small venues, eating cheap, varied ethnic food, seeing sports games, hearing buskers perform music that bounced off the elegant subway tile mosaics, viewing renowned paintings at arm’s length, dance clubbing, watching interesting films in the DOC NYC Fest and rendezvousing with friends from other parts of the metro area, US and world. I’ve shared countless but nonetheless precious, hours with Ellen in the Big Apple doing the above-listed, and other, stuff.
—
New York City hype drove the US Scamdemic. And the continuing distortions of 2020-22 life there will perpetuate widely-held misconceptions regarding The Virus and the response to it. For all their purported toughness and street smarts, during Coronamania, most New Yorkers were neurotic, gullible chumps.
Despite their purported social, economic and cultural mastery, New Yorkers often claim victim status. This week, I saw and heard a grand tale of NYC victimhood when I stumbled upon the final, recent installment of a multi-year, ten-part PBS paean to The City entitled New York: A Documentary Film, directed by non-native New York resident (E)Ric Burns. Alt-spelling his name is a nice touch. It makes him seem more artsy and less WASPy.
Ultimately, the final, two-hour program paints NYC as indomitable, because it has rebounded from the 2001 World Trade Center attack, the 2008 fiscal crisis, 2011’s Superstorm Sandy and, of special interest here, 2020’s Covid Scamdemic.
Some say I should move on from the latter topic. But if it’s still prime time PBS fare, why should I or anyone else stop talking about it?
—
As modern life is full of distractions and most people have short attention spans, there’s too much information to process or remember with specificity. Hence, most people distill events to a few impressions and encode these superficial summaries into their memories, which tend to binary and driven by emotion. Often, how something is portrayed and remembered differs sharply from how it actually was, as in the aforementioned PBS program.
At least regarding Sandy and Covid, Burns and Adam Gopnik, who wrote this recent episode, badly bend the truth. For example, they blame Sandy’s inundation on anthropogenic climate change. But New York is naturally flood prone. It’s nearly at sea level and surrounded by tidal water. Further, building atop many parts of the city was enabled by burying streams and rivers. And as in Boston, which also floods, much New York City acreage, such as that adjacent to the World Trade Center, was created by dumping garbage or other fill into rivers and wetlands. Moreover, as most of NYC is paved and built over, rainwater runs off instead of soaking into the ground. Building and enlarging a super-dense coastal city seems clever. Until it doesn’t.
—
The true Covid story reflects poorly on those who supported the permanently damaging overreaction.
Watching this program made by late-life New Yorkers Burns and Gopnik to pander to an audience of New Yorkers and others who embrace sensationalism, one notices that the filmmakers use many of the cheesy tricks: the hyperbole, buzzwords and catch phrases, the fearmongering, the avoidance of inconvenient truth, the memorable, misleading visuals and statistics, the “don’t be the last one on your block” nudge and the mood-altering music used for decades by New York’s Madison Avenue Mad Men ad creators.
Seeing propagandistic spiky “case” graphs, wailing ambulances, patients hooked to respirators or in body bags atop a soundtrack of mournful violin and slow, single note or minor key piano, PBS viewers who haven’t read or thought independently will become even more wrongly convinced that The Virus killed legions of healthy New Yorkers.
The Covid response was an opportunistic, unprecedented military/ government/media creation. It was never reasonable policy nor “the best we could do, given what we knew at the time.”
While characterizing 2020-22, the PBS narrator grimly invokes such alarming phrases as the “mysterious virus,” the “massive onslaught” of cases and the “horror” of the “beast of death unleashed” by the “unfolding apocalypse” / “plague.” The script also falsely alleges that asymptomatic spread was common and that “the most dire predictions were terrifying.”
Of course they were. Those predictions were designed to terrify. But these were only speculation, built on outlandish assumptions. Even when these models were cooked up and publicized, it was obvious that only the old and very sick were at any risk.
—
The documentary endeavors to sustain the viral mythology by conveying core Covid propaganda, such as alleging that Trump allowed The Virus to enter from Italy by authorizing flights to and from Europe in February 2020. This stance is odd given that Burns and Gopnik note that SARS-CoV-2 was first detected in Washington State in January 2020. It was also found in thawed 2019 blood bank samples from Southern California and other parts of the US.
Further, though PBS doesn’t show this, American Democrats, including New York Mayor Bill DeBlasio, endorsed a low-key approach to Covid until at least mid-March, 2020. On March 2, DeBlasio tweeted New Yorkers “to go on with your lives and get out on the town despite Coronavirus.” On March 9, he said that the “vast majority of New Yorkers, being folks under 50 and healthy, are not in particular danger, and if they were to get it, would experience something like a common cold or flu.” On March 11, he was telling New Yorkers they should “not avoid restaurants, not avoid normal things that people do. If you’re not sick, you should be going about your life.”
If The Virus caused the problems it was said to cause, it was already, widely out of the bag across the US by February 2020. In this vein, the PBS program says nothing about New York State sending infected patients to nursing homes. If Trump encouraged spread, so did DeBlasio and Cuomo. Reportedly caving to staff pressure in late March, 2020, DeBlasio abandoned his initial, sane stance. And during a 2025 interview for the PBS program, he resolutely sold the 2020 crisis narrative.
—
The documentary reports that NYC’s first ostensible Covid victim was an 82-year-old woman with emphysema, likely a longtime smoker, with consequent systemic damage. Though Burns and Gopnik won’t admit it, all or nearly all subsequent ostensible viral victims shared similarly unhealthy, geriatric profiles. At several points, the PBS narrator compares Covid death tolls to those on 9/11. The plain difference is that those killed at the WTC had many vital years left to live.
The program cites, as gospel, the very dubious New York SARS-CoV-2 death tolls. But many, including Dr. Jessica Hockett, have observed that these stats seem wildly exaggerated.
Throughout, CARES Act subsidies incentivized hospitals to attribute to Covid deaths from other causes. It was easy to run up the NYC death toll. There are, in absolute terms, many old, unhealthy people there. There’s also much room for bureaucratic chicanery. I read that a 100-bed nursing home reported 300 Covid deaths in a month. When asked to explain how this could have happened, a nursing home official said it hadn’t reported anywhere near that number of deaths and that someone in the chain of public health statistics must have juiced up that figure. No one was accountable for any statistical anomalies or inaccuracies.
One should also wonder how The Virus killed so many New Yorkers and others after the lockdowns started and masks were widely used. If one believes the official case and death counts, those “spread stopping” measures seem not to have worked very well.
—
PBS asserts that, in response to The Deadly Virus, New Yorkers hid inside for months in 2020. An interviewed fortyish woman says she spent 40-50 days hunkered down indoors. No one should take seriously anyone so afraid of a virus that they wouldn’t go outside for 40 days. In the summer of 2020, after traveling to Manhattan in a nearly deserted, presumably sanitized, NJ Transit train built for 1,500 passengers, I saw midtown streets and sidewalks with very few people on them except for groups of shirtless, shouting homeless men. Somehow The Deadly Virus hadn’t killed these gregarious, unmasked, medically under-resourced individuals. And as PBS points out, during that spring and summer, many reputationally “gritty” New Yorkers had fled to their distant vacation homes.
Burns and Gopnik assert that New Yorkers who sheltered in place survived because undocumented immigrants delivered their takeout orders. While so noting, the filmmakers intend to demonstrate that illegal immigration is saving America, PBS’s praise of immigrants’ food delivery is a self-own: the DoorDash diners willing to subject poor people to risks they wouldn’t take themselves showed a lack of solidarity with The Workers of the World. But the DoorDashers tipped well, so it was all good.
How lazy are people who stay home all day and still won’t prepare their own food? But unshown by the documentarians, NYC grocery stores remained open.
Though the PBS program emphasized how empty the streets were, to promote the memory of crisis, several times it shows ambulances with wailing sirens. Given such light traffic and the availability of oxygen en route, why, other than to build fear, did ambulances use sirens?
—
Burns and Gopnik also insist that the City’s hospitals were overrun. I’ve read that only one of NYC’s many dozens of hospitals, Elmhurst in Queens, nearly reached capacity and then, only briefly so. Presumably, those few who found insufficient ER capacity and attention were already hooked to oxygen and redirected to other hospitals, which were sufficiently empty that their nurses choreographed, recorded and posted dance videos. The PBS program also depicts “field hospitals” in Central Park (which, it noted, hadn’t been done since the Civil War, suggesting some false medical and moral equivalency between that War and the War on The Virus) as well as in the vast Javits Center and the Navy’s biggest hospital ship docked in the Hudson. The documentarians decline to mention that these fear-building, pop-up facilities, ostensibly built to accommodate those turned away from other hospitals, treated zero patients.
The narrator reports that at the viral peak, there were 5,000 new cases/day and that over 1,500 people “went to hospitals.” He doesn’t explain that a “case” was simply a positive test result pursuant to a grossly overinclusive method, that someone who tested positive four times in a week was counted as four cases and that many people, panicked by the Covid doomsday news accounts, went to hospitals with mild cold-like symptoms.
Staying home was a good decision. Going to the hospitals subjected patients to ventilation, lethal sedation and the administration of Remdesivir, each of which caused deaths. The program shows an interview in which a hospital executive admits that four of five intubated New Yorkers died.
In a program interview, a brand-new ER doctor melodramatically told how “a part of me (him) died” when he saw patients die. Shouldn’t an ER doctor expect to see some deaths of old, sick people? Did he know that the Covid treatment protocols departed sharply from time-honored respiratory infection treatments, antibiotics and steroids and that the new methods used to treat Covid patients were killing them instead?
—
For maximum propaganda effect, drone footage shows eight rudimentary coffins being dropped into “mass graves” on NYC’s Hart Island. In Spring 2020, as always, people who lacked kin or the money to fund individual burial space died of something and had to be buried. Over the past century-plus, over a million have been interred in that potter’s field. Burying 2,334—to PBS, that’s “by the thousands”—of over 8.8 million NY residents there in 2020 wasn’t much above the recent annual average. And those buried at Hart could have died of any cause, including old age or medical mistreatment, as did all or nearly all said to have died “of Covid.” The boxes could have been empty. Who took or leaked the footage of the burial?
The filmmakers also trot out images of morgue trucks and falsely imply that these were ubiquitous. Few, if any, bodies ended up inside such these photo-op props.
PBS uses mass grave and fridge truck images to suggest that The Virus caused mass deaths among people of all ages. It’s not true. But combining these images and melancholy music will reinforce watchers’ misguided belief in a Covid catastrophe. It will become their memory.
The film also tries to sell the PC but false notion that Covid was more likely to kill low-income, poor black and brown people. To the extent that The Virus caused deaths, it discriminated, as does nature, on the basis of age, not race or income.
—
Reportedly caving to staff pressure in late March 2020, DeBlasio abandoned his initial, rational low-key Corona response stance. Thereafter, DeBlasio sold the crisis narrative. In the more recent interview done for the PBS program, the politically correct DeBlasio dramatically asserts, “We almost didn’t make it!”
What does that phrase mean? Would a city of 8.8 million fail because a tiny fraction of very old people died slightly earlier than they otherwise would have? Even accepting, for purposes of discussion, the phony NYC Covid death toll, The Virus slightly shortened the lives of the frailest one-half of one-percent of the City’s population.
The film also shows the 7 PM balcony or open-kitchen window pot bangers saluting the “heroes” staffing the lightly used hospitals to falsely convince viewers how overworked the nurses were and how big-hearted New Yorkers are. Instead, it showed how naive and imitative the pot bangers were.
Then, as happy music plays, DeBlasio smiles beatifically at the memory of the twilight percussion and says seeing and hearing them was when he knew New York was going to survive after all. As if that had ever been in doubt.
—
The film also revisionistically suggests that the lockdowns ended as quickly as they safely could have, 78 days after they began. Yet, many public venues remained closed for well over a year. Thereafter, unjabbed entrants remained barred from many events and spaces for another year-plus.
Most importantly, teacher’s unions kept NYC public schools closed for 18 months. PBS, which claims to support equal educational opportunity, never questions why public-school kids were kept home when they and their teachers were far too young for The Virus to kill them. Nor does PBS mention that American private schools and public schools abroad and in some US states either never closed or resumed classes by September 2020 without causing any deaths. Nor, while praising the May 2020 George Floyd marches, does the film mention that these protests violated anti-Covid edicts barring mass gatherings.
—
The program also falsely suggests that the jabs saved everyone and dignifies New-York headquartered Pfizer by noting that this company was founded to make surgical products to aid Northern Civil War soldiers. If Pfizer had been based in Atlanta and made products for Southern soldiers, would its history have been mentioned?
Moreover, Burns and Gopnik conveniently forget that, as they previously admitted, case numbers began to drop in May 2020, when the shots were just a gleam in Pfizer and Moderna stockholders’ eyes. They also fail to mention that the shots failed, as promised, to “stop the spread” and that millions who injected have died or been vaxx-injured.
—
Napoleon said, “History is a series of lies, agreed upon.”
Because the Covid lies absolve Coronamania supporters for the harm they caused, most Americans eagerly agree with these lies, which Burns and Gopnik’s deeply dishonest retrospective seeks to reinforce. Many more false “historical” accounts will follow.
Such films as Plandemic, Collateral Damage and Duty to Disobey have shown how destructive the Covid response was. But neither PBS nor legacy media will air these. Instead, since mid-March, 2020, a phony Covid narrative has been dealt from the bottom of the deck. PBS does so again in this 2026 program.
Whoever decided which Corona lies the media and public officials could tell and which truths must be suppressed is deeply evil. They got away with it because too few people thought critically enough to perceive, call out and defy an obvious Scam.
Thanks, Mark. Sadly, this PBS propaganda will further reinforce the official story in the minds of its uncritical viewership. I know a few people who will use this to reinforce that their view of the scamdemic was indeed the correct one.
How can I send this link to Burns and Gopnik?
COVID-19 Hospital Protocols: Real Stories from Real People.
https://rumble.com/v7fzl66-test.html?e9s=src_v1_cmd%2Csrc_v1_s%2Csrc_v1_s_o%2Csrc_v1_rso%2Csrc_v1_ucp_l
But I feel certain these propagandists would not dare watch these people tell the truth about what happened to them and their loved ones who were killed by the hospital protocols. They were gut wrenching to hear. EVERYONE should listen in order to honor what happened to these souls.